As I walked to my fantastic seat in a crowd full of attendees of all ages and genders in pink wigs, I thought to myself: “none of these people know I am aespa’s number one critic.”
So, what exactly was I, less than a non-fan, doing at aespa’s SYNK : COMPLæXITY tour? I guess I was trying to prove a point, or maybe trying to get them to prove a point to me.
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
INTRODUCTION
First, let me preface. I’ve been deep in the K-Pop sphere since I was a tween and my middle school best friend showed me BTS at a sleepover. I know more about third generation K-Pop than most people, especially girl groups, but I started losing interest around the start of the pandemic as a result of simply getting more into other kinds of music and the disillusion of not being able to see TWICE live because of lockdown.
In my senior year of high school, I caught wind of LOONA’s heartbreaking disbandment. Ironically, this made me find my way back into K-Pop, as I discovered LE SSERAFIM’s debut and NewJeans’ “Hype Boy.” Though originally apprehensive about the concept of a K-Pop “fourth gen,” I quickly learned that the newest girl group wave was chock-full of hit after hit. My first encounter with aespa was their debut song, “Black Mamba,” that I enjoyed pretty thoroughly. It sat on my girl group playlist, but I never dove much deeper into it.
When it comes to K-Pop girl groups, I’ve never cared much for the dark girl crush concept that I find aespa frequently falls into (though the way they execute it is actually totally within my realm, which I’ll dive deep into later). Groups like BlackPink, MEOVV, and BABYMONSTER have huge followings and a lot of generally-well loved songs, but they simply are not my style. This isn’t to say I actively dislike them, but I just enjoy other groups a little better.
This is the part of the backstory where I feel obligated to state that I absolutely adore LE SSERAFIM in all capacities. I saw them during their EASY CRAZY HOT world tour, and am gearing up to see them again in D.C. in early October for their PUREFLOW tour. I am not unbiased, and this is relevant because it’s popularly known that LE SSERAFIM’s fans, dubbed “FEARNOT,” have quite the online rivalry with aespa’s fanbase, known as “MY.”
K-Pop fan wars are incredibly common, and honestly one of my least favorite parts of K-Pop culture. This whole beef started in April of 2024, when LE SSERAFIM took the Coachella stage. Their Week 1 performance sparked a widespread online debate, that in my experience, was more of a hate train. I can confidently say I’ve never quite witnessed a more vitriolic movement towards a K-Pop group in my life, and a lot of the hate was spearheaded by aespa’s fans, eager to prove that their faves were the superior fourth generation girl group. I can’t stress enough how horrifically brutal this hate train was. From then on, I started to develop a strong resentment for aespa’s fans that started to bleed into my perception of the group itself.
Obviously, publicly hating on aespa’s Karina, Winter, Giselle, and Ningning, four young women who don’t have anything to do with any of the decisions made by their fanbase or the company that represents them, is pointless, and only feeds into the never ending cycle of hatred and blame against women. I never felt compelled to hate on aespa online. It’s exactly what LE SSERAFIM went through in 2024, exactly what KATSEYE is going through now, and there are strong roots to explain why it is that girl groups receive far bigger hate trains than their male counterparts. Everything about the impossible standard women in K-Pop have to live up to is enshrouded in misogyny, and I’ll be the first to admit that my own internal resentment for aespa has very little to do with the girls themselves, which is bad. In the vainest of terms, I was angry about the online abuse and death threats my favorite group was receiving online, so I kept trying to find the faults in aespa just so I could balance it all out in my head somehow. Hypocritically, I was still streaming “Black Mamba” and I’d occasionally listen to “Supernova” all the way through when it autoplayed at the end of my K-Pop playlist.
When I got the opportunity to do press coverage for the 2026-27 aespa LIVE TOUR – SYNK : COMPLæXITY, I thought someone with my history of picking the group apart in my head attending their tour and seeing them in their own turf would make for an interesting concert review. My intention going in was not to uncover some huge flaw and write a scathing review on them, but it was instead to let them show me that my unfounded criticism for them was, in fact, unfounded. And, of course, though I try to be as objective as I can be, I’m absolutely incapable of not having a good time at a K-Pop show. There was no way I’d pass it up. It’s in my blood.
The energy inside the venue filled me with excitement and anticipation. The fans showed out, as is common for K-Pop concerts. The outfits I saw were incredibly stylish, with a generally sleek cyber-streetwear style. I also noticed a hilarious amount of people in pink wigs, a reference to Giselle’s inescapably iconic pink-haired look during “Whiplash” era. My girlfriend and I hurried to our seats after getting fries, which ended up not being necessary, as the two and a half hour set had a twenty minute late start. When the lights finally dimmed, however, I quickly scrambled for my earplugs, as I realized pretty immediately that MYs are not messing around when it comes to their intense cheering and support for aespa.
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
ACT 1: SINGULARITY
I feel like VCRs (which, in K-Pop terms, are the pre-recorded, frequently cinematic videos that play on the screens between breaks) are one of the most underrated parts of K-Pop concerts. They can absolutely make or break the atmosphere between artist water breaks and costume changes, and so much time, care, and budget is put into their production. aespa’s VCRs for this tour were exceptionally well done and thought out, communicating a clear story that even a non-fan like myself could understand with ease. My only small qualm with it was that at times text would show up in the center screen, which was hard to see from the sides, and even with the great seats we had, I couldn’t read some of the words on the screen due to the lack of accommodation for the side screens.
The first VCR was the beginning of the story: a music video for “Welcome to MY World,” where the four girls were framed in a cinematic segment, enjoying their girlhood and friendship in nature. I admittedly laughed at the Funion product placement. It was the only one I caught, and it briefly pulled me out of the vibe, but I was quickly re-immersed when the video began to notably glitch, creating the inciting incident: the members must face a distorted, ruptured reality, and find a way to restore it before it consumes them. This first visual segment was a perfect introduction into their cyber hyperfuturistic concept and creative direction, which I’d like to briefly talk about.
Though I’m not really a fan of the dark girl crush concept, I am always going to be pleased by any kind of cyber alien situation. I love the direction groups like XG and ARTMS are going into, and I cannot believe I never found out how much aespa actually dabbled in it. I found, over the course of this concert, that they execute this concept virtually flawlessly, and the visuals were absolutely one of my most favorite parts of the experience. Their creative team for these VCRs had an extremely clear vision that set the tone for the whole show. I loved it.
After this initial intro, aespa’s virtual avatars began to appear on screen, and the group appeared on stage in a reveal that unleashed all built-up energy and anticipation. The audience erupted in screams as the lights shone down on the group, kicking off the five-act show with their newest hit: “LEMONADE.” An unpopular opinion is that I find “LEMONADE” to be one of aespa’s weakest title tracks. It’s catchy, but not in a compelling way, and I find it overall sort of irritating. The VCR had created a lot of tension that I expected to burst in a firework, but I found, rather, that it weakly sputtered into little sparks because of Ningning’s shockingly low energy during the opening lines. Winter quickly picked it back up, clearly making an effort to fight the backtrack with her vocals. The background dancers were fantastic and executed the choreography flawlessly. aespa’s choreography generally relies on cleaner arm and hand movements than any impressive formation changes or footwork, which I’ve often found looks great on Music Bank and Inkigayo fancams, but can quickly become underwhelming when watching a live performance from a seat in the audience. The background choreography was a great fix for this, bringing all of the energy that was missing from the main group’s simpler dancing.
The other main problem that I noticed immediately was Ningning’s lack of stage presence, which unfortunately lasted until the end of the show. This came as a huge shock to me, as Ningning has always been praised online for her visuals and energy, but I think in trying to look cool and effortless, she seemed incredibly disinterested. Her constant lipsyncing also left a lot to be desired, especially considering the fact that she’s the main vocalist and widely regarded as the best singer in the group. She had some great moments, but the lack of changes in facial expression and her lipsyncing when it truly wasn’t warranted left a bad impression on me.
“Switchblade” was the next song on the setlist, followed by “Whiplash.” The intro had the fans screaming loud enough for it to noticeably penetrate my earplugs. I noticed that Winter was really giving the performance her all, fighting the backtrack as best as she could. Out of aespa’s whole discography, “Whiplash” is easily my favorite song. I really enjoyed this performance, and even took a few videos for myself.
The first act neared its end with “Black Mamba,” during which Winter’s voice suffered the slightest crack during a high note, a moment that did not take me out but instead pulled me in closer as I realized her incredible vocals were all live. The last song was “WDA (Whole Different Animal),” and the crowd happily imitated the iconic scuba dance move the group does during the chorus.
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
ACT 2: INVASION
The VCR for the second act featured confessional interviews from the members about the altered reality. Each member spoke in their native language: Karina and Winter in Korean, Giselle in Japanese, and Ningning in Chinese. I found that their line delivery during this cinematic break was incredibly authentic, and I was very impressed by their acting.
The second act served to show a softer side of aespa that their usual concept doesn’t show. It opened with an acoustic version of “Count On Me,” with the members in beautiful white outfits and Karina on piano. It was clear that they were singing live, and Winter and Ningning did a fantastic job on vocals. Giselle seemed to be struggling a bit more, but given her unofficial position as more of a rapper and dancer, I believe she still gave a good performance.
During this opening, two unrelated remarks appeared in my mind: the first, I noticed that the members had not addressed the audience at all by this point, which was kind of a shock to me. There’s usually a good amount of fan interaction in K-Pop concerts, and we’d already gone through a whole act without a talking break. Secondly, there’s a well-known rumor that aespa’s stylists intentionally give worse outfits to Giselle (placed second from the left), and although I hate to believe in a rumor, it’s hard not to when there’s so much evidence. Her outfit was considerably plainer than the rest of the members—especially Karina, who came out with a voluminous, floor length tulle train, a stark contrast to Giselle’s flat, knee length cape.
The songs that followed were “Camouflage” and “Angel #48,” which, though a great showcase of ethereal concepts and soft yet powerful vocals, didn’t stand out much from other average pop tracks. At some point during the second song, Ningning straight up forgot to sing the beginning of her line for a few seconds, letting the backtrack shine in all its glory. When she remembered to sing again, it sounded pretty identical, putting the lipsync in egregious evidence.
This feels like a good moment for me to break down aespa’s song formula, which I noticed about halfway through the show. aespa title tracks seem to follow the same steps: rap-heavy opening verse over bassline, pre-chorus with melodic vocal buildup, and an unpredictable beat drop switch-up during the chorus. The chorus will usually be in English, and employ the use of repetition of a specific word. And who can blame them for perfecting this formula? It has produced charting song after charting song, even awarding “Supernova” the highly anticipated MAMA song of the year award in 2024.
With the slower songs during this act, I found that they simply didn’t stand out to me, which is a shame, because aespa showed fantastic vocals that their usual title track formula doesn’t allow them to display as much. I hope in the future aespa receives vocal heavy title tracks that both suit them and allow them to showcase the full potential of their talent.
After these two songs, the group members finally had a short break where they spoke to the audience. They introduced themselves and thanked everyone for showing up, which is pretty standard for K-Pop shows. A translator interpreted what they said in Korean for the audience.
After this, they performed “Can’t Help Myself,” a noticeably more Western influenced track, with some standout vocals from Winter, and closed out the act with the highly popular originally Japanese recent release “KISS N TELL.” The latter track has always confused me because it seems like such a bizarrely different concept to what aespa usually does. It’s a good song, but it feels like it should’ve gone to Hearts2Hearts based on what they’ve done in the past. There’s nothing wrong with them trying a new concept, but the concept doesn’t seem to be theirs at all, and the visuals feel almost too playful to capture the identity they’ve established up to this point. Karina definitely stood out to me the most during this act — she’s good at subtly prompting and engaging with the audience, and easily commands the stage.
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
ACT 3: CONFINEMENT
The VCR continues to expand on the altered reality lore with more interviews and found footage of the members in a “Backrooms”-like environment. The third act consisted of two duets and four solo performances, one for each member. It started off with some 2D renditions of Giselle and Ningning’s virtual avatars. They were pretty uncanny, and I suspect they were AI generated (aespa has been involved in a couple of controversies in the past over AI generated material), but I could not find anything on the subject. The production studio 88 Gymnastic Heroes was in charge of the VCR material, and the rest of it is, allegedly, done by SM Entertainment’s in-house video producers. 88 Gymnastic Heroes posted a good amount of material they worked on, but these avatar segments were not on their Instagram, and I’ve been unable to find any credits for who made these visuals, if they were made by a human at all.
The first duet was Giselle and Ningning’s “Lollipop,” which was my least favorite performance through the whole show. “Lollipop” is probably the most explicitly sensual song in the setlist. This is not where my dislike for it comes from. I have no problem with songs that explore sexual themes, especially when it seems so stigmatized in K-Pop. Giselle and Ningning actually co-wrote this song with their producer, which is notably rare for idols to do.
My problem with “Lollipop” comes from the fact that its content and performance are undoubtedly looking to appeal to the male gaze, and it was an uncomfortable watch. The lyrics flatter a male listener in full English, with lines like “You’re cuter than my boyfriend” and “I love it when I’m with you, even when I’m taken.” The performance ends with the two girls pretending to embrace each other for the audience, which, paired with lyrics clearly about men, has nothing to do with representation and everything to do with fetishization.
Before I could finish processing my thoughts on it, though, Karina took the stage for her solo, “16 bit.” This was, in my opinion, one of the best performances of the night. It blends EDM with ethereal vocals, and I think it perfectly shows off Karina’s charm and strengths. Although the backtrack was incredibly loud, I really enjoyed the song. I think “16 bit” breaks a bit of aespa’s usual song formula, but brings something fresh, well-crafted, and lyrically deep to the table. Additionally, the choreography was engaging and cinematic, and Karina’s finger gun moment completely blew me away. The background dancers lined up next to her, and with the motion of her hand, she sent an invisible bullet through them, and like dominoes, they one by one curved their backs as if truly feeling the impact. What a phenomenally choreographed and executed moment.
“Saddle Up” was Winter’s solo, introduced by a promotional video showcasing the cowboy concept. Her sleek cowboy outfit paired with the long and straight platinum blonde hair immediately brought Beyoncé’s “Cowboy Carter” to mind. She took the stage and gave a performance that left me with mixed reactions. She seemed exhausted by this point, and couldn’t keep up well with the background dancers, which made the choreography itself feel uninteresting. On two different occasions, she exposed her own lipsyncing pretty evidently, but the moments where she delivered live adlibs were amazing. Winter is undoubtedly an exceptional vocalist, and despite the fact that she was probably very tired during this segment, the parts where she delivered were great.
After Winter finished performing, the screen introduced Giselle’s song, “BYEB4HELLO.” Giselle appeared in the front stage behind just a mic stand. Her silhouette was marked by a beautiful backlight, a very simple yet striking image.
The simplicity did not stop there—she didn’t have any dancers or a more complex set design with her, which the other three songs in the act had so far. I was looking forward to watching Giselle shine on her own, but this one was pretty underwhelming. The lack of other factors would suggest that Giselle has enough vocal and dancing strength to deliver a good performance on her own, but there was no choreography until the very end, and even without dancing she was heavily relying on the noticeably loud backtrack. At some point, the motion design on the screen revealed a pair of washed out eyes, which, paired with her Y2K outfit, felt reminiscent of Evanescence to me. Towards the end of the song, she walked back to the main stage to join her dancers. This is the part where I was expecting my jaw to be left agape, but I found the choreography to be average and not worth too many notes.
That left Ningning’s solo, which I was quite curious about. As I’ve said before, Ningning has been the member that’s left me wanting the most up to this point, with needless lipsync and little stage presence. When her intro video played on the LED screens, the crowd lost their minds, erupting in explosive cheers of support and excitement for her. If I thought Giselle’s setup was simple, Ningning’s was minimal. She walked on stage draped in an angelic white gown, covered in flowers from her neckline to the end of her train on the floor. She sang her song, “I Love You but I Gotta Let You Go,” and it felt like I finally got to see the true potential of her vocal powerhouse. It’s a pretty average ballad, but she did a fantastic job, and I was incredibly impressed by her live singing and stage presence here. There was no dancing, just a heartfelt performance that she delivered quite authentically. All of it was gorgeous. I stand in my belief that SM Entertainment should make more of an effort to give aespa vocal heavy tracks that are actually interesting, so they can shine like this more.
The last song in the act was “Serenade,” which is Karina and Winter’s duet. After reviewing online reactions, it seems like “Serenade” is more popular than “Lollipop,” and I can totally understand why. I really enjoyed the song, finding it to be a more energetic dance track. There was, once again, an unprecedented amount of lipsync, but since Karina and Winter have both been the members most committed to live singing, I was fine with them prioritizing their dancing for this one.
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
ACT 4: AWAKENING
The final VCR concludes the alternate reality story with the four girls restoring their memories and bringing back stability to their reality. I was frustrated by the fact that the VCR only really happened in the center back screen, so even from where I was sitting, I felt like I was missing vital story information because the captions were totally inaccessible.
This act featuredespa’s more famous songs, starting with “Armageddon” and followed by “Bite.” I noted throughout both of these songs that the way Winter and Karina fought the backtrack ended up highlighting just how much Ningning and Giselle relied on it, which was disappointing, considering the show was almost over. They took a break during “Dirty Work,” where their dancers did a short and powerful dance intermission. The next two songs were “Next Level,” which was definitely one of my favorite songs on the set because of the motion design and Karina’s playful engagement of the crowd, and “SHAKIN’,” a song I did not know prior but the Giselle superfan behind me was screaming every lyric to.
The last song of the act was “Supernova,” which is the song I was most looking forward to seeing live. It looked, also, like it was the song they were most looking forward to performing. All four of them were really feeling themselves, and Ningning’s adlib was great. My favorite moment of the song was Karina’s “body bang” line— it was delivered quite well, and displayed her charm in a way that I’d like to call all encompassing. The crowd’s energy was at its very peak during this song.
When the girls went backstage for the last outfit change of the night, the audience participated in “MY TIME,” with “MY” referring to the fanbase’s name. I frequently catch myself smiling during these segments at large K-Pop shows. They usually happen at the end, and they’re basically a dance version of an audience cam. There will be a five second countdown, the chorus of a song will play, and the screens will show the choreography. The camera then pans to a random concertgoer, and the rest of the crowd cheers for them as they perform the dance as best as they can. It’s a fun way to build a sense of closeness, as they last a while and happen right before the end of the show. Additionally, I enjoyed seeing all of the different outfits and costumes that audience members in different sections brought to the show.
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
ACT 5: RESOLUTION
The final act was the shortest — just the encore. It began with a music video for the song “Roll,” that completely killed my amped-up mood created by the preceding act. I’d never heard the song before and was caught off guard by the fact that it samples “Row, Row, Row Your Boat.” Yes — the nursery rhyme. Parodies of them have become increasingly popular in K-Pop, and it never fails to make me cringe. In trying to create some kind of playful irony, I find that they always end up coming off as extremely corny.
“YEPPI YEPPI” was the second-to-last song the group came back out to perform. This song was fun, though it felt more like an Itzy song. I’m also sure it would’ve been even more fun if Giselle had not lipsynced the whole thing, but I’ll admit I did shimmy a little.
The group briefly addressed the crowd a second and final time, politely thanking the audience for showing up, and we all took a group photo.
Their last song was “Til’ We Die,” a song highlighting their gratitude and appreciation for their fanbase. They assure the audience of their unwavering love through a heartfelt vocal performance. The show ended after that, with concertgoers collecting confetti from the grounds and venue staff preparing the VIP sections for send-off.
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
FINAL THOUGHTS
My main thought through the course of the show was that I was truly unaware of aespa’s visual game and creative direction. They have a very strong concept going for them, and I found myself not as engaged when they deviated from it for certain performances. I think their cyber reality aesthetic is very well executed while still distinguishing itself from other groups that are known for similar visions, like XG and ATEEZ. I was incredibly impressed by the VCR work and thought it to be some of the best I’ve seen in K-Pop shows, though, to be fair, this is a style that I am already biased towards and that appeals to me greatly. I thought it was phenomenal.
The members themselves, as the main part of the show, left me with quite mixed opinions. On one hand, there is no doubt at all that the four of them are incredibly talented and hardworking young women. I mean, I’ve been seeing it even before this show — the K-Pop journey to debut is grueling, and there has to be steady improvement and an intense drive. Going into it, I wanted to be intentional about my own perceptions with the awareness that most of the hate and scrutiny aespa receive is rooted in misogyny. There is an impossible standard these women need to meet, and if they fall slightly short, they are met with vitriol and abuse from people who do not know them and have not a single stake in the conversations where they smear them. These girls are absolutely picked apart as a result of any choice they make in the public eye as well as other factors they cannot control, such as SM Entertainment’s business decisions and even their own appearance. And their appearance will be critiqued no matter what. I want no part in that. I’ve seen the way women are destroyed online over things no one would question if a man did them, and I think it’s gross and unfair. As a result, I refuse to comment on aespa’s appearance or give any judgement other than what I, a non-fan and reviewer, saw on stage that night.
With that said, I thought it was a good, standard K-Pop show. I think that aespa finds most of their strength in their vocals, which isn’t to say they’re bad dancers. The choreography, to me, seems intentionally designed to give them enough stability to sing the relatively demanding high notes, and also to look really good in a fancam or as a TikTok challenge. But because the choreography isn’t super impressive, I was let down by the fact that there was so much lip-sync, especially for a group that is known mainly for their singing.
I have a feeling this may have to do with the lack of general breaks. The members got to go backstage and change outfits during Act 3, when each of them had a solo and a duet with another member. This means each member only performed two songs out of the six total, but I think they should have been awarded more talking breaks during the other acts in order to not only boost fan interaction and engagement but also let them breathe a little bit. I’ve been to several K-Pop girl group concerts, and this is the show where the members addressed the audience the least. Usually, these portions include lengthier conversations with the crowd and are a part of what makes each tour stop unique.
aespa only talked once at the beginning to introduce themselves, and once at the end to thank MY for coming out and supporting them, but there wasn’t a lot of variety in their messaging. None of this is a real issue, but my main concern is that giving them such limited and short segments to talk to the fans limits the amount of time they get to sit still and breathe without having to worry about hair, makeup, and outfit changes. The setlist is extremely long (though, after looking for it online, I found that a couple other songs had already been cut out, meaning the setlist was originally even longer), and I can’t imagine how exhausting it must have been for them to have to deliver all of these tracks.
Unfortunately, the overall diminished energy did make the experience less enjoyable, which I wouldn’t say is the members’ fault directly. I do wish I had gotten to see the stage presence Ningning fans rave about online. I was hoping at some point she would seem less disinterested, but her expression remained the same until the end of the show, and she lipsynced most of it except for the important high notes and her own solo. Her skill and beauty definitely shone through during her solo song, so I know for a fact that she’s exactly as talented as MY say she is, I just didn’t see much of any energy from her throughout the show.
Karina absolutely demonstrated what it means to be the leader and center of aespa. Her stage presence got even more eye-catching by the end, which I don’t see particularly often. She engaged with the audience the most for sure. Winter also stood out to me with her vocals. She sang live, even when she wasn’t completely confident, and delivered a solid performance in spite of the extensive setlist.
As for Giselle, I don’t really know. She has definitely mastered her portrayal of her unbothered and iconic idol persona, and I thought the way she acted on stage reflected this well without seeming detached or dismissive. She came off the same way she does in online videos and variety shows, which comes to show she knows exactly what to do and say to communicate who she is to an audience, no matter how large. Sadly, though, I don’t think her setlist did her any favors. She lip-synced a majority of it, and I believe she deserved a solo with way more of an interesting choreography in order to showcase more of her talents beyond singing. Additionally, the styling differences did seem pretty blatant, which made me kind of sad. Those last two points aren’t on her at all, but it’s worth bringing up as they seem to be limiting her.
At the end of the day, I was there to let aespa prove a point to me, and the point was proven before the show even started—they never did anything to warrant any hate. This show was not enough to turn me into a fan, and I doubt that anything will. It’s hard for me to get really into music when I don’t like the music that much, but that’s okay. What I did learn from this is that aespa is a girl group who worked incredibly hard to get to stages like this one, and that they’re all individually gifted in their own areas. I’ll definitely tune into whatever they release next, but beyond that, all I can do is hope they continue to grow and flourish while knowing they have a hyper-dedicated audience right behind them.
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
